Payson Utah Real Estate | Homes for Sale

FreeBuying or selling in Utah? Olivia's clients get My Home Booklet free: warranties, home records and maintenance reminders in one easy app.

Ask Olivia See the App

Looking for homes for sale in Payson, Utah? This guide shows every active MLS listing in Payson, from townhomes and starter homes to newer family neighborhoods and larger lots, updated every morning at 9:00 AM.

Payson is a city of about 21,000 people near the south end of Utah Valley, below Mount Nebo. It has a historic downtown, strong community traditions and home prices that are often lower than in the north end of the county. Buyers come for the small-city feel, quick I-15 access and the mountains right at its edge.

Where Is Payson, Utah?

Payson sits south of Spanish Fork and Salem, with Elk Ridge on the bench to the east and Santaquin to the south. I-15 runs through the west side of the city, putting Provo about 25 minutes north and Lehi about 45 minutes away. Payson Canyon and the Nebo Loop Scenic Byway start at the city's southeast edge, with trails, campgrounds and fall colors.

Payson Neighborhoods

Historic downtown: older homes on tree-lined streets near Main Street, Memorial Park and the historic tabernacle site.
East bench: larger homes with views of Mount Nebo near the mouth of Payson Canyon.
West Payson: newer subdivisions and townhomes near I-15 and the Payson Utah Temple.
South Payson: family neighborhoods and open land toward Santaquin.

History of Payson

Pioneer families led by James Pace settled along Peteetneet Creek in 1850, and the town took its name from Pace. Farming and orchards shaped its early years, and Payson grew into the main town of south Utah County. The city still celebrates its farming roots with Onion Days each Labor Day weekend and hosts a Scottish festival every summer. Movie fans may know Payson as a filming location for the 1984 film Footloose.

Thinking about Payson? Olivia Pelton works with buyers and sellers across Utah County, from starter homes to land and larger lots in the south end of the valley. Ask Olivia about a Payson home.

Real Estate Guides Near Payson

Payson Homes by Price

Not sure what fits your budget? The affordability calculator shows a realistic price range in about a minute.

Payson Homes Under $300,000

List View
Map View
Grid View

834 GREENRIDGE AVE, Payson, UT

834 GREENRIDGE AVE
Payson, UT

$299,000
- Lot Size
  
  872 sqft
- Home Size
  
  1,070 sqft
- Beds
  
  2 Beds
- Baths
  
  2 Baths
451 N 500 W #39, Payson, UT

451 N 500 W #39
Payson, UT

$75,000
- Lot Size
- Home Size
  
  1,000 sqft
- Beds
  
  2 Beds
- Baths
  
  1 Bath

See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of 11/13/2026)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.

Payson Homes $300,000 to $450,000

List View
Map View
Grid View

443 E 100 N, Payson, UT

443 E 100 N
Payson, UT

$450,000
- Lot Size
  
  14,811 sqft
- Home Size
  
  2,250 sqft
- Beds
  
  5 Beds
- Baths
  
  3 Baths
1618 N 1280 E, Payson, UT

1618 N 1280 E
Payson, UT

$315,000
- Lot Size
  
  872 sqft
- Home Size
  
  1,443 sqft
- Beds
  
  2 Beds
- Baths
  
  3 Baths
1964 W 1190 S, Payson, UT

1964 W 1190 S
Payson, UT

$392,900
- Lot Size
- Home Size
  
  1,791 sqft
- Beds
  
  3 Beds
- Baths
  
  2 Baths

See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of 11/13/2026)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.

Payson Homes $450,000 to $600,000

List View
Map View
Grid View

443 E 100 N, Payson, UT

443 E 100 N
Payson, UT

$450,000
- Lot Size
  
  14,811 sqft
- Home Size
  
  2,250 sqft
- Beds
  
  5 Beds
- Baths
  
  3 Baths
150 E 500 S, Payson, UT

150 E 500 S
Payson, UT

$470,000
- Lot Size
  
  21,780 sqft
- Home Size
  
  2,400 sqft
- Beds
  
  4 Beds
- Baths
  
  1 Bath
816 N 600 E, Payson, UT

816 N 600 E
Payson, UT

$450,000
- Lot Size
  
  9,148 sqft
- Home Size
  
  2,100 sqft
- Beds
  
  5 Beds
- Baths
  
  2 Baths

See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of 11/13/2026)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.

Payson Homes Over $600,000

List View
Map View
Grid View

2895 W 790 S, Payson, UT

2895 W 790 S
Payson, UT

$1,150,000
- Lot Size
  
  5.25 ac
- Home Size
  
  3,776 sqft
- Beds
  
  6 Beds
- Baths
  
  3 Baths
1374 N 1560 E #136, Payson, UT

1374 N 1560 E #136
Payson, UT

$629,900
- Lot Size
  
  7,841 sqft
- Home Size
  
  3,461 sqft
- Beds
  
  3 Beds
- Baths
  
  3 Baths
1361 N 1600 E #151, Payson, UT

1361 N 1600 E #151
Payson, UT

$813,451
- Lot Size
  
  7,841 sqft
- Home Size
  
  4,109 sqft
- Beds
  
  7 Beds
- Baths
  
  5 Baths

See all Real estate matching your search.
(all data current as of 11/13/2026)

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.

Payson, UT Real Estate Listings

The listings below show every active property in Payson, newest first, refreshed every morning at 9:00 AM. Get new listings first to receive new Payson listings by email; you can unsubscribe at any time. Found a home you like? Send Olivia a quick message and she'll help you look into it before you make an offer.

Recent Real Estate Activity in Payson

Olivia Pelton has helped buyers and sellers in Payson.

Olivia Pelton

3/13/2026

Near 1380 South, Payson UT 84651

My clients are now the proud owners of a 5-bedroom, 3-bath home of about 2,620 square feet in Payson, UT. I was glad to help them find it and get…

Helped my buyers get the keys W 1380 S, Payson, UT

Olivia Pelton

12/19/2018

Near West 800 South, Payson UT

I helped my clients purchase a home in Payson, UT and represented them from the offer through closing. Congratulations on the new place!

Closed on a Home for My Buyers in Payson UT

Jim D

I purchased my first home about a year ago. Olivia was my agent, and she was AMAZING! We went from not even thinking we could buy, to living in our new home very quickly. The process was smooth and easy, and everything was explained! Thank you, Presidio, and thank you Olivia!!

Holly Smith

Olivia was very friendly and personable, she met all of my expectations!!! She also went above and beyond helping me with securing the best price in having the water heater & HVAC inspection done❗️ She offered on many occasions to help me complete any task in my home to prepare for the sell. We connected on so many levels, Olivia was a star in selling my condo 🤩 and I got exactly what I wanted from the sell Thank you Olivia 💝

kristie Weber

Olivia was very helpful in all aspects of selling our house. Very knowledgeable on everything we needed to do. I would highly recommend her for anyone looking to sell a house.

Mahrooz Maddela

I have known Olivia Pelton since 2018, when my husband and I moved here from Dallas, Texas. From the very beginning, she was efficient, kind, friendly, knowledgeable, and always willing to go the extra mile to help us find the right home. Not only did Olivia help us find exactly what we were looking for, but she continued to check in with us from time to time to see if there was anything else she could help with. She consistently went above and beyond in ways I had never experienced with a realtor before. During our home tours, Olivia would ask thoughtful questions of the contractors and builders that we would never have thought to ask ourselves. Her expertise, attention to detail, and genuine care gave us tremendous confidence throughout the process. Over the years, our professional relationship has grown into a lasting friendship. I wholeheartedly recommend Olivia to anyone looking for a realtor who is knowledgeable, dedicated, and truly cares about her clients. She is simply the best!

Serena Aeschilman

Olivia sold me my second house. She really takes time for her clients. She follows up and goes to bat for the wants I have! I love doing business with Olivia because I know that she’s as invested in my happiness as I am. I highly recommend working with Olivia! I’ve referred some peers to her and they are also happy with her! Olivia is fantastic! A friend recommended her and I do not regret it. For starters, when I first contacted her, she was AT DISNEYWORLD on vacation. She answered all my questions while she was enjoying a day with her son. I was very impressed that she was willing to do that! From then on, she would promptly reply to any text I sent, day or night. I was very happy to almost instantly get a reply! She made the transition to closing very smooth and assured that any questions I had, as a new time home buyer, were valid. She even brought up points that I had forgotten when I sat down with the buyer. I was so glad I had her by my side to assist in the process. I bought a new construction home and she showed up to EVERY meeting. The reps of Woodside were surprised she came because apparently, realtors don't typically go to those. I am so thankful she did. She pointed out flaws that I did not catch. During the final walkthrough, she truly advocated for me and my concerns. She ensured my concerns were valid and that the builders heard them. She went out of her way a few times to listen to me when I was upset over things that went wrong. Olivia did try her best every time where she could. We even used Ranlife's lender and Olivia even chatted with the lender when things went awry. My dad assisted throughout the way as well. He does own property and was impressed by Olivia. His previous realtors did not advocate for him and did not attend all the showings as Olivia did. Olivia is now the family realtor! I will recommend her to anyone I hear is looking for a realtor because I am so grateful I had her by my side! I will definitely be coming to her again in the future. To top it off, I had mentioned I was buying a house to get a dog! When I closed, she gifted a house warming crate that had dog supplies! I'm so impressed she remembered the dog comment!!

Collin Genin

Olivia is amazing. Very respectful and proficient She helped us find a home and not just sell us a house. I'll definitely be coming back for any of my real-estate needs!

Trax Decker

Olivia is and will be the best Realtor you can get. My wife and I had been looking for a home for several years, serious to semi-serious looking. Once we had our first meet, not only did we find a home, but her professionalism, her attitude and direction, her awesome personality and sense of humor, made this experience far better. I loved loved loved how she provided us with what we asked for. Too many time did I tell other Realtors that we had a specific pay range, yet still got home listings 300k-600k more than we could ever afford. Not with Olivia. Call her, call her yesterday! She works hard, be honest with her and she will get you into the home you were meant to be in like she did for us! We still look at our home and feel so grateful to be in it, then we text her and tell her! I highly recommend Olivia, and thanks again for our wonderful home!

matt dynan

Olivia goes above and beyond to make your real estate transaction fun, professional and worry free. I’ve worked with many different realtors over the years and Olivia is hands down the most hard working and professional realtor I’ve ever dealt with. Olivia blew me away with her attention to detail, insight, advice and knowledge of the market. Most importantly, she is an amazing person with a wonderfully positive personality. I enjoyed working with her and would highly recommend her services.

Marlo Taylor

Olivia has helped us with a purchase and sale of our home. She is the most patient, flexible and hard working realtor we have ever worked with! 5 stars isn’t enough! Thank you so much Olivia! We could not recommend her enough!